Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
skip to main |
skip to sidebar
2008-05-21
What's the deal with those big black CDs? Neill's Vinyl Conversion Project (VCP) which will eventually become the Tape Conversion Project (TCP). This is an effort to both preserve and enjoy my audio library.
From Crawdaddy
2008-05-21
Possibly relevant links
- Greatest singer/songwriter albums of all time
- Vinyl LP Comeback = Wishful thinking
- Record store story
- CD Sales down, LP Sales up?
- Putting a New Spin on Vinyl Records
- Making Room for Analog Records in a Digital World
- Better sound formats
- Vinyl Comeback
- CNN bit on Vinyl Comeback
- Home Recording Act
- Grateful Dead discography
It takes a lot to laugh
Background
I want to explain how and why I'm doing what I'm doing.
It's about enjoying and at the same time preserving the audio art. Years ago I recognized the deleterious impact that playing records had on the media. In their own way, records were a defective product because their very use ultimately destroyed them. One way of dealing with this was to copy the records to tape (cassettes in my case) and enjoy them that way. The tapes had the added benefit of being playable in cars.
Enter the digital era....
The ease of handing and the durability of CDs made the ordeal of playing a vinyl record album look pretty burdensome. Sure, there are those purists and audiophiles who decry the thin, flat sound of CDs but that's a different subject. To my ear, the CD that I can make from an album is a more faithful reproduction than I've ever been able to get from a tape. Taking the CD one step further and loading it on a computer opens up new worlds. That along with an iPod, addresses the portability issue. So.... digital is one obvious way to preserve the original media and still enjoy the art.
Some time early in this century I began the process of converting my LPs to CD. That process experienced surges and lulls over the years and continues to this day.
It's about enjoying and at the same time preserving the audio art. Years ago I recognized the deleterious impact that playing records had on the media. In their own way, records were a defective product because their very use ultimately destroyed them. One way of dealing with this was to copy the records to tape (cassettes in my case) and enjoy them that way. The tapes had the added benefit of being playable in cars.
Enter the digital era....
The ease of handing and the durability of CDs made the ordeal of playing a vinyl record album look pretty burdensome. Sure, there are those purists and audiophiles who decry the thin, flat sound of CDs but that's a different subject. To my ear, the CD that I can make from an album is a more faithful reproduction than I've ever been able to get from a tape. Taking the CD one step further and loading it on a computer opens up new worlds. That along with an iPod, addresses the portability issue. So.... digital is one obvious way to preserve the original media and still enjoy the art.
Some time early in this century I began the process of converting my LPs to CD. That process experienced surges and lulls over the years and continues to this day.
Hardware
I've heard the mainstream PC described as an electronically "dirty" environment. A minor grounding problem in an audio environment might create a hum that would be unacceptable for listening to music, but in a computing environment, such a problem is almost always a non-issue.
When I first looked into the idea of converting analog audio to digital, one obvious solution was to use the "line in" jack found on many computer soundcards. The "Sound Recorder" software that came with early versions of the Windows operating system looked like it should enable this capability but this approach was fraught with complications and in my opinon many of those problems still exist today despite many advancements in hardware and software.
My conclusion was that performing the initial analog to digital conversion outside the computer system using components dedicated to the purpose was the way to go. My thought was that once the music has been digitized, the computer was more than up to the task of managing the bits and bytes.
My first CDR (Compact Disc Recorder) was a Philips 775. Just about as the original 1 year warrenty was about to run out, I got an offer in the mail to purchase an extended warranty from the manufacturer. "Psheww... extended warranties are for suckers" I thought. I pitched the letter in the trash. A day or two later the machine exhibited some very unsettling behavior and ceased to function. I rummaged madly through the trash and recovered the letter and purchased the warranty and got the machine repaired under terms of the extended warrenty a week or two later. Within less than a year, the machine failed again and this time, the warrenty program opted to replace the machine with a new 0ne (CDR-795) which was effectively an upgrade in terms of features and performance. That second CDR deck lasted several years and I never again heard from the manufacturer regarding renewing the extended warrenty. Eventually that machine failed and I replaced it with the current Sony machine (RCD-W500C) which I believe is the only such piece of equipment being sold by Best Buy.
The CDR deck behaves very similarly to a cassette deck but the media is CD instead of tape. Like many later cassette decks, all three of my CDR decks have been dual bay. That makes it possible to dub from one CD to another but I've very rarely used the machine that way.
When I first looked into the idea of converting analog audio to digital, one obvious solution was to use the "line in" jack found on many computer soundcards. The "Sound Recorder" software that came with early versions of the Windows operating system looked like it should enable this capability but this approach was fraught with complications and in my opinon many of those problems still exist today despite many advancements in hardware and software.
My conclusion was that performing the initial analog to digital conversion outside the computer system using components dedicated to the purpose was the way to go. My thought was that once the music has been digitized, the computer was more than up to the task of managing the bits and bytes.
My first CDR (Compact Disc Recorder) was a Philips 775. Just about as the original 1 year warrenty was about to run out, I got an offer in the mail to purchase an extended warranty from the manufacturer. "Psheww... extended warranties are for suckers" I thought. I pitched the letter in the trash. A day or two later the machine exhibited some very unsettling behavior and ceased to function. I rummaged madly through the trash and recovered the letter and purchased the warranty and got the machine repaired under terms of the extended warrenty a week or two later. Within less than a year, the machine failed again and this time, the warrenty program opted to replace the machine with a new 0ne (CDR-795) which was effectively an upgrade in terms of features and performance. That second CDR deck lasted several years and I never again heard from the manufacturer regarding renewing the extended warrenty. Eventually that machine failed and I replaced it with the current Sony machine (RCD-W500C) which I believe is the only such piece of equipment being sold by Best Buy.
The CDR deck behaves very similarly to a cassette deck but the media is CD instead of tape. Like many later cassette decks, all three of my CDR decks have been dual bay. That makes it possible to dub from one CD to another but I've very rarely used the machine that way.
Software
I use the following software in connection with my analog conversion process:
Media Player (ripping and playing at home)
Goldwave (editing)
iTunes (loading iPod)
Picassa (cropping album art when I photograph the jacket)
Sonic (disc copy)
Windows features (Windows Explorer, Backup)
I should look into what is the service inside of Media Player that I use to look up track and artist data from the Web.
iTunes uses Gracenote which I have some experience with from my old mini disc days.
Media Player (ripping and playing at home)
Goldwave (editing)
iTunes (loading iPod)
Picassa (cropping album art when I photograph the jacket)
Sonic (disc copy)
Windows features (Windows Explorer, Backup)
I should look into what is the service inside of Media Player that I use to look up track and artist data from the Web.
iTunes uses Gracenote which I have some experience with from my old mini disc days.
Process
All of the CDR decks that I've had work only with recordable discs that have the "Digital Audio" banner as part of the Compact Disc logo.
My current process involves me pressing a button on the CDR remote to mark the tracks. There are clearly other ways to do this and having to "babysit" the album is a burden, but I've concluded that this is actually the most efficient process I can devise. However it's VERY easy to slip up and miss a track mark. If using a recordable CD discs, there isn't really anything that can be done to fix a missed track mark. On the other hand, if I'm using a rewritable (CD-RW) discs, the CDR deck will allow me to back up and try again. The limitation is that I can only erase by whole tracks. Still, this beats making stacks and stacks of coasters. After recording the source to the CD-RW disc and finalizing the disc, I move that disc to the PC.
I then use Media Player to rip the CD-RW to the "My Music" folder on my Entertainment Center PC. But before ripping I use Media Player's "Get Album Info" option to download the album and track titles from the web. Overall, I probably am able to download this information about 90% of the time. In the exceptional case, I enter this information myself.
If I rip the album BEFORE entering or downloading album and track information, Media Player will put the album in a folder labeled "Unknown Album..." and the tracks will also be named generically. If I enter the album and track titles, AFTER having ripped the album to the PC, Media Player will recognize the revision but the underlying folder names and track file names will not be updated. I prefer the folder and track names to jive with the names as they appear in Media Player.
Photographing album art from the LP.
Custom tags
My archival CD-ROM copy
System backups
Blogging
Unfinalizing and Erasing the CD-RW disc for re-use
My current process involves me pressing a button on the CDR remote to mark the tracks. There are clearly other ways to do this and having to "babysit" the album is a burden, but I've concluded that this is actually the most efficient process I can devise. However it's VERY easy to slip up and miss a track mark. If using a recordable CD discs, there isn't really anything that can be done to fix a missed track mark. On the other hand, if I'm using a rewritable (CD-RW) discs, the CDR deck will allow me to back up and try again. The limitation is that I can only erase by whole tracks. Still, this beats making stacks and stacks of coasters. After recording the source to the CD-RW disc and finalizing the disc, I move that disc to the PC.
I then use Media Player to rip the CD-RW to the "My Music" folder on my Entertainment Center PC. But before ripping I use Media Player's "Get Album Info" option to download the album and track titles from the web. Overall, I probably am able to download this information about 90% of the time. In the exceptional case, I enter this information myself.
If I rip the album BEFORE entering or downloading album and track information, Media Player will put the album in a folder labeled "Unknown Album..." and the tracks will also be named generically. If I enter the album and track titles, AFTER having ripped the album to the PC, Media Player will recognize the revision but the underlying folder names and track file names will not be updated. I prefer the folder and track names to jive with the names as they appear in Media Player.
Photographing album art from the LP.
Custom tags
My archival CD-ROM copy
System backups
Blogging
Unfinalizing and Erasing the CD-RW disc for re-use
My first choice would be...
Blog Archive
-
▼
2006
(9)
-
▼
December
(9)
- Good Old Boys - Pistol Packin' Mama (Round RX-109 ...
- Commander Cody and His Lost Planet Airmen - Tales ...
- Commander Cody and his Lost Planet Airmen Country ...
- Jimmy Buffett - Christmas Island
- David Bromberg - Demon In Disguise (Columbia C3175...
- Elvin Bishop - Let It Flow
- The Allman Brother Band - Idlewild South
- Van Morrison - Moondance (Warner Bros. 1835 - 1970)
- Emmylou Harris - Quarter Moon in a Ten Cent Town (...
-
▼
December
(9)
Labels
- 60s (23)
- 70s (80)
- 80s (21)
- 90s (1)
- Analysis (1)
- Bluegrass (15)
- Blues Rock (6)
- Cajun (1)
- Christmas (2)
- Comedy (2)
- Compilation (1)
- Country (4)
- Country Pop (1)
- Country Rock (19)
- Dawg Music (19)
- Diversion (4)
- Documentary (2)
- Female Vocal (12)
- Folk Rock (5)
- Have CD (2)
- Hillbilly Jazz (1)
- Jazz (5)
- Jazz Rock (1)
- Male Vocal (6)
- New Wave (5)
- no album art (2)
- Parody (1)
- Pop (5)
- Process (9)
- Progress report (6)
- Reggae (1)
- Rock (26)
- Singer-Songwriter (29)
- Soft rock (5)
- Sound clips (1)
- Soundtrack (1)
- Southern Rock (4)
- Souvenir (2)
- Spoken Word (1)
- Surfer (1)
- unknown year (6)
- Various Artists (1)
No comments:
Post a Comment